Despite putting in an assured display, praising lots of clubs and managers, Evans remains a figure of hate and ridicule in the football world - outside Rotherham of course.
And true to form, Twitter came out to play when the programme aired with a mixture of insults and praise for the Scot.
Here's a look at some of the tweets that got Steve Evans trending on Saturday night and Sunday morning.
Steve Evans looks like....
Steve Evans looks like an alcoholic, man-sized-placenta. #FLS #FootballLeagueShow
— Kevin Hoare (@UkuleleKev) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans looking like a bloated Andy Gray.
— Joshua Simons (@J_Simons102) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans looks ill
— Matt Fawcett (@matt_b_fawcett) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans is on the football league show. He looks like a gene splice experiment between a red jelly baby and an aborted fetus #BigRedBaby
— Tom Lovegrove (@tomlovegrove94) October 25, 2014
Is it me or is Rotherham manager Steve Evans a dead ringer for Den Perry off of #PheonixNights ? #thefootballleagueshow
— John Burdon (@jjbred7) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans looks like a tramp who's been attacked with some clippers and booted through Primark.
— Jack Lewis (@JakLew89) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans has a face like a pork pie #footballleagueshow
— H (@harryw79) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans looks like one of those weird transsexuals you'd only find on a channel 4 documentary
— Jacob (@JacobMorley8) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans is an odd mix of Cheggers, Bobby Davro, John McGinlay and Mrs Brown. #fls
— tony coffey (@TheTonyCoffey) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans looks like the drummer from a mid-80's New Romantic band on a present day nostalgia tour. #footballleagueshow
— Ben Wright (@wrightben) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans, the love child of Meatloaf and Freddie Starr
— Aidan (@puremint91) October 25, 2014
Some were quick to cotton on to his choice of clothing....
Steve Evans proved the old adage that black makes you look slimmer to be utter nonsense. #fls #chubbypiegobblingcunt #stfc
— T doggy dog (@TrevorSTFC) October 26, 2014
Sound thinking by Steve Evans, wearing a black shirt....he looked very slim & lithe π
— ⓇⓄⒷⒷⓄ (@RobboSTFC) October 26, 2014
Someone told Steve Evans "wear black, it'll make you look thinner on tv" not worked has it...
— John (@Johnnee66) October 25, 2014
The 'black is always slimming' rule doesn't really apply to Steve Evans.
— Charlie Meyler (@charliemeyler) October 25, 2014
This is a favourite line of attack....
The woman who had to do Steve Evans make up must be calling the Samaritans by now
— Steve Aspinall (@SteveyAsp) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans barely recognisable on Football League Show without his make-up
— Andrew Collon (@andyc_128) October 25, 2014
Has the BBC budget on make up been spent on Steve Evans??
— EwoodEAGLE (@theewoodeagle) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans has so much makeup on on ftball league show. Surely if he was at all concerned about his appearance he'd do summat about his gut
— Eeeeeaad (@hodders5) October 26, 2014
@htfcworld every time I see Steve Evans I think he's got the perfect face for slapping on plenty of make up...
— Alan Rees (@archivist_al) October 25, 2014
"So Steve Evans..." pic.twitter.com/tGA45TRvxo
— growlershot (@growlershot) October 25, 2014
He did win some plaudits, though....
Everyone hates Steve Evans but I reckon he seems a sound bloke!
— Mathew Howe (@MathewHowe) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans is a class manager though, you have to give him thatππ #fls
— Astrid✨ (@astridheath) October 25, 2014
Being unbiased steve Evans is actually alright at punditry
— Mash (@ThatPavementKid) October 25, 2014
Can I just say thought Steve Evans (Rotherham manager) has conducted himself spot on tonight #footballleagueshow
— Lee Byers (@RedLeedo) October 25, 2014
Steve Evans talks well on #FLS
— Chris Shepherd (@Sheppiii) October 26, 2014
Thought Steve Evans spoke very well on football league show. Clearly loves & knows his football. Bidding for joey garner is a bit cheeky!
— Craig Critchley (@CjCritch) October 26, 2014
Have to agree with @tdobbs20 Steve Evans excellent on the FL show. Pleasantly surprised.
— Craig Jefferson (@Jaffa113) October 26, 2014
@OfficialRUFC Steve Evans - honest, complementary of other deserving teams, credible and without doubt genuine. Love him
— Andy Shaw (@AndyShawLawyer) October 26, 2014